DBSA Statement on Fiscal Year 2004 Budget
National Institutes of Health and National Institute of Mental Health
The following written testimony was submitted to the House
Appropriations Subcommittee on Labor, Health and Human Services and
Education on May 23, 2003 as part of this year’s public witness
hearings. The testimony focuses on the need to increase the National
Institutes of Health and the National Institute of Mental Health’s
budgets for FY2004 and other vital mental health initiatives for
patients living with depression and bipolar disorder.
TESTIMONY OF LYDIA LEWIS
PRESIDENT, DEPRESSION AND BIPOLAR SUPPORT ALLIANCE
Chairman Regula, Ranking Member Obey, and distinguished members of
the Subcommittee. My name is Lydia Lewis, and I am the President of the
Depression and Bipolar Support Alliance (DBSA), formerly known as the
National Depressive and Manic-Depressive Association. Our organization
appreciates the opportunity to submit testimony in support of increased
funding of the National Institutes of Health (NIH) and the National
Institute of Mental Health (NIMH) as proposed in the President's Fiscal
Year 2004 budget request.
Astonishingly, one out of four people in
the United States still believe that people with untreated mood
disorders are dangerous, according to a recent public survey conducted
by DBSA. Clearly, stigma is still an issue that people living with
mental illness face every day. This is one of the reasons that DBSA
changed its name late last year. Our Board of Directors recognized that
for many of the 20 million American adults living with depression and
the 10 million adults living with bipolar disorder, the term "manic
depression" is frightening and keeps many people from contacting us
for help. Since our name change, we have found that our use of the term,
bipolar disorder, which has gained widespread usage among clinical and
medical professionals in recent years, has made it easier for many
people to contact us for assistance. And so, Mr. Chairman and members of
the Committee, please know that even at a time when our society goes to
great lengths to enhance understanding and remove stigma, for many
people living with depression and bipolar disorder, that has not yet
happened.
Take, for example, the experiences of
one, 43-year-old woman who was diagnosed with bipolar disorder and
turned to us for help. She lives in a small community where, she told
us, people "see any kind of mental problems as being crazy."
"I try to hold my head up," she
wrote us, "but there are times that it is unbearable. The way
people look at you and whisper or just have nothing to do with you. I am
not crazy. I have been medicated for six years, and I see my doctor. I
am not to blame."
Mental illness should be no different
than physical illness in our society's perceptions; people do not choose
to be mentally ill. It is this type of stigma that DBSA is committed to
removing and asks that members of Congress work with us to do so.
DBSA is the leading patient-directed
national organization focusing on the most prevalent mental illnesses -
depression and bipolar disorder. DBSA's mission is to improve the lives
of people living with mood disorders. This not-for-profit organization
fosters an environment of understanding about the impact and management
of these life-threatening illnesses by providing up-to-date,
scientifically based tools and information, written in easy to
understand language. DBSA has more than 1,000 peer-run support groups
across the country. Our organization works to ensure that people living
with mood disorders are treated equitably Over two million people
request and receive information and assistance from DBSA each year.
Assisted by a Scientific Advisory Board, comprised of the leading
researchers and clinicians in the field of mood disorders, DBSA supports
research to promote more timely diagnosis and to develop more effective
and tolerable treatments and to discover cures.
In that regard, we are grateful for this
Committee's support over the past five years for the much needed
doubling of funding for the NIH. This commitment was a resounding
recognition by Congress of the pressing need to address the serious
public health issues related to mental health.
NIH AND NIMH BUDGET REQUEST
Far too often, businesses and government agencies fail to recognize the
very real, economic impact that results when individuals with depression
or bipolar disorder fail to seek treatment, either through fear or a
lack of sufficient information. An estimated 44 million Americans
experience a mental disorder in any given year and only one-fourth of
them actually receive mental health and other services. The World Health
Organization has pronounced unipolar depression as the leading cause of
disability in the world. In established market economies like the United
States, mental illness accounts for more than 15 percent of the burden
of disease. That is more than the disease burden caused by the
combination of every form of cancer. One out of every four American
women will experience major depression in her lifetime, and 10 to 15
percent of women develop postpartum depression the first year after
giving birth. As a result, many of these mothers are unable to
adequately bond with their babies, increasing the risk of future
depression in their children. In fact, experts say these babies are at
an increased risk of depression throughout life. In all, by some
estimates the economic toll of untreated mental illness, through
absenteeism or interrelated illnesses, is roughly between $50 and $80
billion annually from lost work days and other related costs.
This is a burden our nation can avoid
through a commitment to sound research, accessible mental health
services, aggressive programs to reach out to individuals with mood
disorders and by removing the stigma of mental illness. DBSA supports
the President's request to Congress for $27.89 billion in funding for
the NIH, including $1.38 billion for the NIMH, both of which represent
modest funding increases above the current fiscal year. In light of
DBSA's mission, we would, of course, be lax in our duty if we did not
urge the Committee to consider raising these amounts. However, we
recognize the significant gains that have been made in the past five
years and the fiscal challenges that Congress currently faces. I would
simply ask that, at a minimum, the Committee continue its longstanding
commitment to providing the resources to combat mental illness and to
avoid any setback to future years' funding levels for NIH and NIMH.
MENTAL HEALTH INITIATIVES IN CONGRESS
AND THE EXECUTIVE BRANCH
The New Freedom Commission on Mental Health appointed by the President
has recently completed its series of public hearings as part of its
study of the country's mental health service delivery system, including
both the private and public sector providers. The Commission was tasked
with advising the President on methods to improve the system so that
adults with serious mental illness and children with serious emotional
disturbances can live, work, learn, and participate fully in their
communities. As the committee is aware, this Commission was the first
comprehensive study of the nation's public and private mental health
service delivery aimed at improving the mental health delivery system.
DBSA commends the President for his commitment in this area and for
affirming that with proper treatment, individuals living with mental
illness can, indeed, participate fully in society.
Among the initial findings of the
Commission are a number of areas that DBSA recognizes and supports,
including the assertion that "mental health is essential to
health." DBSA has been very active in drawing attention to the fact
that mental illness does not occur in isolation, but often instead with
such illnesses and conditions as heart disease, stroke, immune
disorders, diabetes, cancer and neurological illnesses like Alzheimer's
and Parkinson's disease.
This linkage, known as co-morbid illness,
demands more attention from both policy makers and the medical
community. Currently, it is commonly believed that depression is an
inevitable part of chronic illness. The truth is, depression is a
separate illness that frequently co-occurs with illnesses like diabetes
and coronary disease. Research has indicated that depression often
precedes and helps trigger the onset of diabetes. And the Journal of
American Medicine has reported that "major depression may play a
role in an increased risk of death and hospital readmissions for
patients with congestive heart failure." Overall, medical
treatments have a greater success rate if co-occurring depression is
treated. More research is needed to determine the causal relationships
involved in co-morbid illness.
In its outline of the final report that
is to be submitted shortly to the President, the New Freedom Commission
noted another area in which DBSA has been active: co-occurring disorders
pertaining to drug and alcohol abuse. In my testimony before the
Commission in September of last year, I focused my remarks on the scope
of this problem. The rate of alcohol and drug abuse in the general
population is approximately six percent. Among individuals with bipolar
disorder, that rate increases to between fifty and sixty percent. The
Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration (SAMHSA)
recently reported to Congress that seven to ten million individuals in
the United States have at least one mental disorder as well as an
alcohol or drug use disorder. Many researchers and clinicians believe
that both disorders must be addressed as primary illnesses and treated
as such. The SAMHSA report discussed a number of evidence-based
interventions and programs that demonstrate improved outcomes with
integrated services and treatments.
The New Freedom Commission on Mental
Health and SAMSHA both made recommendations for treatment of
co-occurring disorders that comport with and, in fact, highlight the
significance of DBSA's support services. These recommendations involve
integrating peer support and consumer input into the treatment process.
The Commission took special note of the effectiveness of peer support in
the treatment process, calling for these services to be fully integrated
into the continuum of community mental health care.
Meanwhile, the very foundation of DBSA as
a patient-directed organization is mirrored in SAMHSA's findings that
"consumers and recovering individuals bring special characteristics
that support the recovery of individuals from both substance and mental
disorders: subjective knowledge of the service delivery system, empathy
for the struggles related to the process of recovery, a capacity to
build rapport and fundamental respect for the integrity of each
person."
I urge the Committee to support SAMHSA's
recommendations, including the establishment of a national center for
technical assistance, treatment, prevention and cross-training for
co-occurring disorders that will ultimately improve the quality of life
for patients and their families.
Another worthy recommendation of the
President's New Freedom Commission on Mental Health was to accelerate
research to enhance prevention of, recovery from and ultimate discovery
of cures for mental illnesses. There are many others, which I will not
address here, but I look forward to the final report of the Commission.
In Congress, DBSA continues to urge the
passage of H.R. 953, the Senator Paul Wellstone Mental Health Equitable
Treatment Act, and its companion Senate bill, S. 486. A majority of the
members of the House and Senate are now cosponsors of this legislation.
The President has said he supports it, yet this legislation continues to
remain on hold in Congress. There is no scientific, financial or ethical
justification for the artificial distinction between physical and mental
illness in insurance coverage.
Moreover, this inequity is one of the
biggest remaining obstacles to removing the stigma that still surrounds
mental illness.
The same can be said for a similar
inequity for co-payments under Medicare for mental health services. At a
time when depression and bipolar disorder are recognized as serious
health problems in the elderly population, Medicare recipients who seek
mental health services must pay 50 percent of the fees for those
services. Individuals seeking Medicare payments for treatment of other
illnesses pay only 20 percent of a physician's fee. DBSA supports
pending legislative initiatives in Congress to provide parity for
Medicare co-payments.
As noted earlier, postpartum depression
among new mothers, the most under diagnosed obstetrical complication in
America, is a significant problem for both affected women and their
children. H.R. 846 and its companion bill in the Senate, S. 450, seek to
direct funds for NIH research related to postpartum depression and
postpartum psychosis. DBSA strongly supports this legislation.
In conclusion, we must be pro-active and
committed to addressing mental illness in this country with no less
vigor than we have for other public health issues. Removing stigma is
the first step in getting individuals to seek the help they need. That
is why the issue of parity in insurance coverage and federal health
programs is so key for the Congress to address. We must be committed to
providing access to mental health services. And we must not abandon our
support for sound research at the NIH and NIMH to prevent, provide
recovery from and find cures for mental illness. Each year, 30,000
people die by suicide in our country - even more than die by homicide.
We believe many of these unnecessary and tragic losses can be prevented
through increased availability of treatment and cutting-edge research to
expand treatment options.
Mental illness is not solely an issue
reflected in the toll that it takes, when not addressed, on the lives of
individuals and their families. It is a national problem whose less
apparent but still very real impacts unnecessarily threaten the
employment and financial health of the country. There are very real
financial costs that arise from untreated mental illness, through lost
productivity, absenteeism and co-occurring illnesses. And, of course,
there are millions of real people whose lives are affected. I thank the
committee for recognizing that untreated mental illness is a national
problem and that addressing it not only is fiscally sound public policy,
it is the right thing to do.
I appreciate the opportunity to submit
this testimony and thank the Chair, Ranking Member and members of the
Committee.
|